[Accepted] Reapply Shadowmourne fix

#1 » Post by **Justicelight** » 20 Jun 2016 01:10

While seeing attempts to nerf SM in pvp scene, I would like to suggest re-applying the SM fix, for PvE purposes. Ofcourse this will not limit its usage for battlegrounds, but it will give the SM weilders a more realistic aproach in their path to maximum dps in the PvE scene.

Please give options to this poll and post your support on this idea as a comment. Just be subjective, if you want another suggestion, please open another topic.

#2 » Post by **Gnurg** » 20 Jun 2016 07:42

Could you summarize the difference between current and how it should be? No wall of text, please.

If neither of the arena suggestions are applied, I don't want any buff to SM.

#3 » Post by **Justicelight** » 20 Jun 2016 07:48

It should generate fragments from often than it is curently doing, this is more or less what the fix would do.

#4 » Post by **Regent** » 20 Jun 2016 08:10

Current Version: 50% chance for a soul fragment on all auto attacks and melee abilities.
Fixed Version: 20% chance for a shard fragment on auto attacks. 100% chance for a soul fragment on all melee abilities including non-damaging ones like Sunder Armor and Hamstring. 1 fragment on applying rend. 2 fragments for some abilities like Scourge Strike and Plague Strike.1-8 fragments per Whirlwind . 1-2 fragments per Heart Strike and Cleave. 1 fragment each for all paladin melee abilities & dps seal procs.

Sources: (and a full list of all all abilities + the # of soul fragment stacks they generate).
http://wowwiki.wikia.com/wiki/Shadowmou ... _Fragments
https://github.com/TrinityCore/TrinityCore/issues/1619

#5 » Post by **Errorista** » 20 Jun 2016 12:02

Well some DPS boost will not hurt with recent ICC fixes

+1

#6 » Post by **Justicelight** » 20 Jun 2016 18:46

Bumpin` this.

Let`s give it a vote.

#7 » Post by **Relina** » 21 Jun 2016 09:09

Justice you might want to change the 1st post to emphasis that this will only happen if SM or its proc is banned from arena/battlegrounds (lets be honest if those pvpers get their way with changing arena's they'll start to qq about Bg's next and the staff will give into their demands).

Anyways +1 from me.

#8 » Post by **Crymaker** » 21 Jun 2016 14:03

#9 » Post by **mcheka** » 21 Jun 2016 15:43

#10 » Post by **Hansrutger** » 21 Jun 2016 16:15

Big +1!!! I've been waiting for this since Justicelight created that other SM topic!

Regent wrote:Current Version: 50% chance for a soul fragment on all auto attacks and melee abilities.
Fixed Version: 20% chance for a shard fragment on auto attacks. 100% chance for a soul fragment on all melee abilities including non-damaging ones like Sunder Armor and Hamstring. 1 fragment on applying rend. 2 fragments for some abilities like Scourge Strike and Plague Strike.1-8 fragments per Whirlwind . 1-2 fragments per Heart Strike and Cleave. 1 fragment each for all paladin melee abilities & dps seal procs.

Sources: (and a full list of all all abilities + the # of soul fragment stacks they generate).
http://wowwiki.wikia.com/wiki/Shadowmou ... _Fragments
https://github.com/TrinityCore/TrinityCore/issues/1619

And no you are incorrect, the current version is not 50% on all auto-attacks. It is 20%.
http://www.truewow.org/forum/viewtopic. ... adowmourne

#11 » Post by **Regent** » 21 Jun 2016 17:00

Hansrutger wrote: And no you are incorrect, the current version is not 50% on all auto-attacks. It is 20%.
http://www.truewow.org/forum/viewtopic. ... adowmourne

So it's even lower than I expected. Lovely.
Changes nothing about how it's supposed to be in the first place.
And I already read that topic a month ago, but thanks for trying anyway.

#12 » Post by **Amoriann** » 21 Jun 2016 17:39

+1 x XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

#13 » Post by **testeromir** » 09 Jul 2016 14:04

+1 in any case and if proc gets disabled in arenas then I see no reason that this is not fixed, so in that case +2.

#14 » Post by **Dropdead** » 09 Jul 2016 16:33

-1

Especially if its the old fix full of bugs that made it even more op than it should be , plus this wont affect pve only , it will buff it in pvp aswell (bgs , duels , world pvp) and we all wanted it nerfed in pvp didnt we?

#15 » Post by **Jiranthos** » 09 Jul 2016 17:22

Removed the flames and non-contributing posts. Keep it calm.

Existing user Log In