[CLOSED] Guild PvE Progression Thread
- freakout9903
- Posts: 26
- Joined: 15 Jun 2015 21:53
Re: Guild PvE Progression Thread
DTP July 6th
~ Killed Terestian Illhoof ~
~ Killed Shade of Aran ~
~ Killed The Curator ~
~ Killed Romulo & Julianne ~
~ Killed Maiden of Virtue ~
~ Killed Moroes ~
~ Killed Attumen the Huntsman & Midnight ~
~ Killed Terestian Illhoof ~
~ Killed Shade of Aran ~
~ Killed The Curator ~
~ Killed Romulo & Julianne ~
~ Killed Maiden of Virtue ~
~ Killed Moroes ~
~ Killed Attumen the Huntsman & Midnight ~
Re: Guild PvE Progression Thread
Logic 5th of July
-Attumen
-Maiden
-Moroes
-Opera
-Attumen
-Maiden
-Moroes
-Opera
Re: Guild PvE Progression Thread
https://i.gyazo.com/5f0b7e091114d0b76b5 ... 4c2f79.jpg
HKM, Gruul
Prince, Shade, Illhoof, Curator, R+J, Maiden, Moroes, Attumen dead 7/08/2017
HKM, Gruul
Prince, Shade, Illhoof, Curator, R+J, Maiden, Moroes, Attumen dead 7/08/2017
Re: Guild PvE Progression Thread
Logic 8th of July High King Maulgar
- diawowwrath
- Posts: 56
- Joined: 07 Apr 2016 02:39
Re: Guild PvE Progression Thread
Logic will no longer be participating in this list as it just became clearly questionable in some creative editing.
Re: Guild PvE Progression Thread
https://gyazo.com/454bd9b9b48ed64a6b1ac8b0eb6d3991
Netherspite and Nightbane killed.
Karazhan cleared July 9th.
Netherspite and Nightbane killed.
Karazhan cleared July 9th.
Last edited by kurthos on 09 Jul 2017 08:04, edited 2 times in total.
Re: Guild PvE Progression Thread
What are you talking about?diawowwrath wrote: ↑09 Jul 2017 06:25Logic will no longer be participating in this list as it just became clearly questionable in some creative editing.
Re: Guild PvE Progression Thread
diawowwrath wrote: ↑09 Jul 2017 06:25Logic will no longer be participating in this list as it just became clearly questionable in some creative editing.
Hi, I talked to the GM of <REBORN> yesterday and he told me that they cleared up to and including Prince Malchezaar on day 1.
I looked at achievements and saw that <REBORN> got the Karazhan achievement(for killing Prince) at 00:03:28 on the first day, I then looked at Natnat from <Logic> and saw that their Romulo and Julianne kill happened after midnight, so at the earliest around the time that <REBORN> killed Prince Malchezaar, after that I looked at the Twitch stream that <REBORN> raiders hosted and saw that they killed Romulo and Julianne over 2 hours prior to that, ergo <REBORN> killed everything from R&J up to and including Prince Malchezaar before <Logic>.
Now, maybe <Logic> went in earlier in the day and killed Attumen, Moroes and Maiden, I just assumed that since <REBORN> were at least 2 hours ahead of you on R&J that they also got those first, but if you claim that <Logic> got those 3 before <REBORN> then I will edit my original post and the burden of proof remains on <REBORN> since you posted first.
This is all done in accordance to the previously stated rules and goals of the thread, namely:
I'll be trying to keep track of this on my own by checking guilds' armory, etc, but I highly encourage every guild to post their progression here.
if a dispute arises between who killed a boss first a proof will be asked for(such as a killshot with a timer) and in the absence of either guild being able to provide one the guild that posted first will be put ahead on the list.
- diawowwrath
- Posts: 56
- Joined: 07 Apr 2016 02:39
Re: Guild PvE Progression Thread
Kurthos, shut it fool.
Natnat wasnt in the first raid.
I really don't care, but some of my guildies do care about this dumbshit. Editing the list 3 days after the fact for a guild that's not even posting their information into the list seems awfully fishy.
"if a dispute arises between who killed a boss first a proof will be asked for(such as a killshot with a timer) and in the absence of either guild being able to provide one the guild that posted first will be put ahead on the list."
Natnat wasnt in the first raid.
I really don't care, but some of my guildies do care about this dumbshit. Editing the list 3 days after the fact for a guild that's not even posting their information into the list seems awfully fishy.
"if a dispute arises between who killed a boss first a proof will be asked for(such as a killshot with a timer) and in the absence of either guild being able to provide one the guild that posted first will be put ahead on the list."
Re: Guild PvE Progression Thread
I literally edit the list several times/day to try and keep it accurate, not to favor the first guilds to post or whatever.
I checked the 4 highest ranked members in your guild with any Karazhan kills, Gehere, Natnat, Spacetanche and Rageheart. Only one of those 4 with anything in their activity log about when they killed Opera is Gehere who received loot from Opera on July 6th, presumably shortly after midnight server time since as far as I know the raid started on July 5th server time.
If that is the case then <REBORN> clearly killed Opera before <Logic> and as such will be listed above <Logic> for Opera. If you have any information whatsoever to show me that <Logic> killed Opera first then feel free to provide it and I will fix the list.
I can't FORCE every guild to participate in this list, but that doesn't mean they will not be included, if guilds participate then the list will have a greater chance of succeeding and being accurate and will make my job a heck of a lot easier but when I'm told that a certain guild killed certain bosses ahead of another guild and I'm given proof of that happening, as was the case with <REBORN> and <Logic> on Opera, then I will update my list to reflect the most accurate information I have at my disposal.
I checked the 4 highest ranked members in your guild with any Karazhan kills, Gehere, Natnat, Spacetanche and Rageheart. Only one of those 4 with anything in their activity log about when they killed Opera is Gehere who received loot from Opera on July 6th, presumably shortly after midnight server time since as far as I know the raid started on July 5th server time.
If that is the case then <REBORN> clearly killed Opera before <Logic> and as such will be listed above <Logic> for Opera. If you have any information whatsoever to show me that <Logic> killed Opera first then feel free to provide it and I will fix the list.
I can't FORCE every guild to participate in this list, but that doesn't mean they will not be included, if guilds participate then the list will have a greater chance of succeeding and being accurate and will make my job a heck of a lot easier but when I'm told that a certain guild killed certain bosses ahead of another guild and I'm given proof of that happening, as was the case with <REBORN> and <Logic> on Opera, then I will update my list to reflect the most accurate information I have at my disposal.
Last edited by Mizzeeh on 10 Jul 2017 01:36, edited 1 time in total.
- Fitzpatrick
- Honorary Member
- Posts: 470
- Joined: 21 Jan 2016 19:34
Re: Guild PvE Progression Thread
Were talking about Kara? Kara?! [/Iverson off]
Honestly I didnt even know the order even signified anything as DTP was bouncing around. When the difference is hours, between one-shots, does who was first even matter? Talk to me when we get to Lady Vashj and KT.
Thanks again Mizz for the work and time spent on this.
Honestly I didnt even know the order even signified anything as DTP was bouncing around. When the difference is hours, between one-shots, does who was first even matter? Talk to me when we get to Lady Vashj and KT.
Thanks again Mizz for the work and time spent on this.
- Fitzpatrick
- Honorary Member
- Posts: 470
- Joined: 21 Jan 2016 19:34
Re: Guild PvE Progression Thread
<DTP> defeated Prince, Nightbane on the 9th
Per https://truewow.org/armory/guild.php?n= ... ty&realm=p
Per https://truewow.org/armory/guild.php?n= ... ty&realm=p
- nimblesaccount
- Posts: 2
- Joined: 06 Jul 2017 19:14
Re: Guild PvE Progression Thread
just posting because apparently i need to have more activity before i can send messages, needed to send a message to GM about my transfer request but i can't because i'm locked out of sending messages. Oh the world we live in..
- Fitzpatrick
- Honorary Member
- Posts: 470
- Joined: 21 Jan 2016 19:34
Re: Guild PvE Progression Thread
Make a ticket in game? Use the IRC chat bridge at the top right of this page? Jump on the discord (info on the homepage)?nimblesaccount wrote: just posting because apparently i need to have more activity before i can send messages, needed to send a message to GM about my transfer request but i can't because i'm locked out of sending messages. Oh the world we live in..
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest